Date
: January 2004
The
State of the Tiger - India's Tiger Crisis
Pench Tiger Reserve is the real land of Mowgli,
" The Kipling country " and the area of the famous ''The Jungle
Book". Rudyard Kipling was awarded the first noble prize for literature
in 1907 for his brilliant work, which includes the jungle book. There existed
a real human child who was nurtured by wolves. This child was caught by Leut.
John Moor under the guidance of Col. William Sleeman in 1831. Rudyard Kipling
took the clue from Willium Sleeman's writing on Wolf nurturing childrens and a
book on "Camp life of Seoni" by R.A. Sterendale
Fish Mafia
The Exploitation of Protected Areas
Indian legislation clearly protects Tiger Reserves and National Parks under its
Wildlife Protection Act and Forest Conservation Act. Despite this politicians
and Forest Department officials have colluded with criminal interests to allow
commercial fishing in the core area of Pench Tiger Reserve in Madhya Pradsesh
which borders Pench National Park in Maharashtra, a newly designated Tiger Reserve.
The commerical proponents of fishing have argued that local people have traditional
rights to fish in Pench Tiger Reserve. This is despite all the evidence that local
people were not historically dependent on fishing since the Pench River is not
perennial and the reservoir was only completed in 1990. In addition, no traditional
fishing rights were claimed when the area was designated as a Reserve Forest in
1878.
Pench's Powerful Fishing Lobby Threatens Tiger Reserve
Fishing in the core area of Pench Tiger Reserve has already seriously affected
this prime stretch of tiger habitat. Poachers have entered the park in the guise
of fishermen1,4 and official records show that between 1992 and 1996, eight tigers
and 16 leopards were known to have been poached in Pench Tiger Reserve. There
were a further 98 poaching cases detected on prey species in the same period with
at least 27 chital and sambar among the victims.1,2 Fishermen are also illegally
extracting timber from the islands inside the reservoir1, and when captured, fish
poachers have set fire to the forest in retaliation.
Dedicated senior
forest officers have been transferred at crucial times and other staff have been
beaten in outbreaks of serious violence.
"Traditional Fishermen"
Exposed
When the dam and reservoir were built, seven villages were
relocated and compensated by the Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra State Irrigation
Departments to make way for the reservoir which was to submerge their agricultural
land. Four of the villages in Madhya Pradesh were originally forest villages located
by the Forest Department as a labour force.
In May 1996 the Chief Wildlife
Warden of Madhya Pradesh, Mr PK Mishra, instructed the Director of Pench to issue
305 permits for fishing in contravention of the Wildlife Protection Act. This
number was derived from the electoral list for the four forest villages previously
moved and compensated. An analysis of these 305 people shows that most now live
25 km from Totladoh Reservoir and some up to 100 km away.
In 1995, the
Maharashtra Fisheries Development Corporation and the Maharashtra Forest Minister
offered to accommodate the Totladoh fishermen at a tank just outside the Pench
National Park, but they refused. One forest officer has commented that this "indicates
that some vested interests are misguiding the fishermen to continue illegal fishing
at Totladoh".
The Fish Mafia - Exploiting the Poor
The Madhya Pradesh Fisheries Development Corporation (MPFDC) formed an illegal
fisheries co-operative to exploit the fish in the reservoir as early as 1987.3
The "Fishermen Association of Totladoh", claimed to represent 700 families
who reportedly were dependent on fish from Totladoh pond. The Totladoh colony
was established in Maharashtra purely for the duration of the dam construction,
but the former labourers continue to reside illegally inside the National Park.
Instead of the usual system, where fishermen pay a royalty of Rs 12
(35 UScents) directly to the MPFDC, a network of traders set up a system where
they pay the royalty and pay the fishermen Rs 10 (28 UScents) and supply them
with boats and nets. The traders then sell the fish at a market value of around
Rs 50 (US$1.43) per kg.
At the peak of illegal fishing in 1994, the annual
recorded catch was 700 tonnes of fish which represents US$240,000 in royalties
and a market value of US$1 million, but Forest Department staff believe this was
only half of the total catch and that the profit from unrecorded catches were
split between politicians, administrators and the local police.
The
Mafia have offered everyone with access to a vehicle large sums of money to transport
the illegally caught fish. Even the former Park Director was offered US$20,000
if he would co-operate, but he refused.
A Fishy Business - The Politics
of Collusion
Instead of upholding national legislation and fulfilling
a commitment to the Tiger State, Kamal Nath, The Union Minister for Environment
and Forests at the time, and the man behind the Tiger State concept, failed to
take any action. It is widely believed that the decision to encourage fishing
is tied to the election taking place at the time.
The situation was further
confused when, in 1995, the former chief of all of India's wildlife, Mr S.C.Dey,
wrote to the Forest Secretary of Madhya Pradesh, hinting that the State government
could exploit loopholes in the Wildlife Protection Act to allow fishing to continue.9
He suggested that under Section 35(6), fishing was beneficial to the management
of the Park in spite of all the problems highlighted previously by members of
the Steering Committee of Project Tiger. Mr S.C.Dey later reversed his position
and wrote complaining that the issuance of fishing permits in Pench Tiger Reserve
was unlawful.
Silencing Opponents - Honest Men Transferred
As the case was fought in court, the Director, Mr S. Mukharia and Deputy
Director, Mr CK Patil of Pench Tiger Reserve continued to oppose the political
manoeuvres of their seniors and tried to stop the illegal fishing. On January
11th 1997 they were transferred "without prior approval of the Central government
and probably in contravention of the guidelines of the Steering Committee of Project
Tiger and in violation of the Election Commission's code of conduct.
The transfer of honourable senior staff serves to demoralise others and Kamal
Nath himself had stated in 1995 that transfers of good staff, "conveys the
wrong signal that poaching Mafia have influence in high places". Yet he did
nothing to stop it.
Illegal fishing activity escalated following their
departure and within two weeks the Maharashtra Forest Department had written to
the Madhya Pradesh Forest Department requesting that they take immediate action.
EIA was informed that on 27th January 1997, a Range Officer was seriously beaten
by fishermen from Totladoh. Having caught fishermen poaching, he and his staff
were attacked by a mob of 20-30 people. The Officer was beaten and threatened
with fake harassment charges from the village women.
He was dumped in
the forest with a serious head wound and despite calling for help from the Totladoh
wireless camp, his seniors failed to come to his rescue. He finally called the
Maharashtra Forest Department who took him to hospital and to the police.
Supreme Court Fails to Stop Illegal Fishing
In March 1997,
the Supreme Court issued it's final judgement - a compromise, allowing the 305
permits to be issued, but under tight restrictions with all additional costs to
be met by the Forest Department. Despite this illegal fishing continues unabated.
In October 1997, it was reported that as many as 800 individuals were still fishing
illegally.
A further incident of mob violence against forest guards has
been recorded. The fish Mafia continue to use violence and the 305 permit holders
as a screen for their illegal activities.14 Without support from their seniors,
field staff are reluctant to take on the fishermen because of the violent repercussions.
One Range Officer in Madhya Pradesh stated that only 140 out of the 305 people
issued with permits actually fish. It is also reported that many permit holders
have been forced to sell their permits to middlemen. A special vigilance squad
that is supposed to patrol the reservoir has been formed but does not conduct
daily patrols.
BBC NEWS
Vet drug 'killing Asian
vultures'
Scientists believe they have identified the main cause behind
the catastrophic decline seen in Asian vulture numbers.
In the past
10 years, population losses of more than 95% have been reported in three raptor
species across many areas of the Indian sub-continent.
Lindsay Oaks'
research team has now shown the birds are dying after eating the carcasses of
livestock treated with the common veterinary drug diclofenac.
Dr Oaks,
backed by The Peregrine Fund, reports her work in Nature magazine.
"This
discovery is significant in that it is the first known case of a pharmaceutical
causing major ecological damage over a huge geographic area and threatening three
species with extinction," the US researcher from Washington State University
said.
The three species are the Oriental white-backed vulture ( Gyps
bengalensis ), the long-billed vulture ( Gyps indicus ) and the slender-billed
vulture ( Gyps tenuirostris ).
All three are now classed as critically
endangered.
Experimental work
The birds succumb to
kidney failure and visceral gout. Early signs that the raptors are affected can
be seen from the way they hang their heads down to their feet for long periods.
Such has been the alarming decline in bird numbers that international
organisations have pumped hundreds of thousands of pounds into research to track
down the cause of all the deaths.
Now, Dr Oaks and colleagues have found
high residues diclofenac in dead vultures in the field.
They have also
been able produce similar patterns of disease in experimental vulture colonies
fed the drug either directly or via carcasses of buffalo or goat that had been
treated with diclofenac.
Other possible causes of death, such as poisoning
by mercury or arsenic or infection by viruses, have been investigated and ruled
out.
Diclofenac is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug that has been
in human use for pain and inflammation for decades. The veterinary use of diclofenac
on livestock in South Asia has grown in the past decade.
Pivotal
role
The Nature report has led ornithological and other conservation
groups to call for the immediate withdrawal of diclofenac from use.
"Vultures
have an important ecological role in the Asian environment, where they have been
relied upon for millennia to clean up and remove dead livestock and even human
corpses," said Dr Munir Virani, a biologist for US-based Peregrine Fund,
and who coordinated the massive field investigations across Nepal, India, and
Pakistan.
"Their loss has important economic, cultural, and human
health consequences."
One immediate impact has been the explosion
in feral dog populations which have moved into areas no longer scavenged by vultures.
Britain has invested significant research time and money on the vulture
problem through its Darwin Initiative for the Survival of Species.
Dr
Debbie Pain, a research scientist at the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds,
said: "In the 1980s, [ Gyps bengalensis ] was thought to be the most abundant
large bird of prey in the world, but in little over a decade, the population has
crashed by more than 99%, with the loss of tens of millions of birds.
"The decline of Asian vultures is one of the steepest declines experienced
by any bird species, and is certainly faster than that suffered by the dodo before
its extinction. If nothing is done these vulture species will become extinct."
NICK GORDON TO MAKE FILM ON LEGENDARY JIM CORBETT
New
Delhi: The worlds most renowned wildlife filmmaker Nick Gordon recently
completed the first ever film on the wild jaguar which took him 9 years. On visiting
Corbett National Park to see the Tiger he was so enamored by the legend of the
hunter-turned-conservationist Jim Corbett that he decided to make a film on him.
The shooting is planned to start January 2005 and the project should take 2 years.
Research has already begun with Corbetts great grandniece living in Kenya,
contacted for information on rare manuscripts and any objects lying with her that
belonged to Jim Corbett. Gordon will weave the story around Corbetts
life, the legacy he left behind and on the tigers or Corbett Park who are the
descendants of the famous maneaters that Corbett killed.
Date
: December 2003
Asian Vulture Population Project: we need your
help!!

As
you will be well aware populations of Gyps vultures in south and southeast Asia
are in dire trouble. Already extinct as breeding species through much of their
former range in southeast Asia, populations of Gyps vultures have fallen dramatically
across the Indian subcontinent during the last decade.
Work in India has
recorded declines in excess of 95% in populations of three species across 12 Indian
states since the early 1990s (Oriental White-backed Vulture G.bengalensis, Long-billed
Vulture G.indicus, and Slender-billed Vulture G.tenuirostris).
In Pakistan
the situation is also very serious with Oriental White-backed Vulture populations
down by a massive 92% between December 2000 and 2003.
To help vulture
conservation efforts, we urgently need to identify the location of all remaining
breeding colonies of each species throughout their range. This information will
be openly available to conservation planners, national governments, non-governmental
organizations, and individuals > working to prevent the extinction of the species
affected.
The huge geographical area occupied by these species is too
great for any individual > or organization to survey alone in the short time
available. For this reason The Peregrine Fund has developed the Asian Vulture
Population Project to record and monitor changing vulture populations over time
using the internet to gather and disseminate up-to-date data provided by volunteers
across Asia.